The Great Reversal: Why Trump's Key Voters Are Turning Away

The Cracks in the Coalition: Two Key Groups Turning on Trump

Meta Description: Uncover the data on two critical voting blocs—young voters and voters of color—who are turning on Donald Trump since the election. A deep dive into the economy, immigration, and shifting political loyalties.

The 2024 election was defined by a seismic shift in voter coalitions, particularly for Donald Trump. While he managed to secure a significant victory, data from CNN's senior political data reporter, Harry Enten, and other major polling organizations reveals a curious and potentially dangerous trend for the Republican Party. The very voters who helped propel Trump to victory—young people and voters of color—are now showing signs of buyer's remorse.

This report delves into the data to explore why these two pivotal demographics, which were central to Trump's success in November, are now turning away from him. It's a story of an unfulfilled promise, economic anxieties, and a fragile coalition that is already beginning to crack.

The Post-Election Political Honeymoon is Over

For any incoming president, the first months in office often include a "honeymoon period" of strong public support. However, for Donald Trump, this period has been unusually short and is showing signs of a sharp reversal, especially among specific demographics. According to a Pew Research Center analysis, Trump's overall job approval rating stands at 38%, a modest decline from 41% just two months earlier.[1] While a 3% dip may seem small, a CBS News poll shows a dramatic and disproportionate decline among one group in particular: young voters.[2]

The post-inauguration data paints a grim picture. Trump's job approval rating among Americans ages 18-29 has plummeted from a high of 55% just after he was inaugurated to a mere 28%.[2] This represents a more than double-digit drop, a decline that is more than twice as large as the decline seen in any other age group.[2] The steepest drop has been observed among less partisan and politically engaged young people, including half of the independents under 30 who approved of Trump in February but have now withdrawn their support.[2] This rapid shift indicates that what seemed to be a "permanent rightward shift" among young voters might have been a temporary phenomenon, or a fragile coalition built on unfulfilled promises.[2]

The sentiment is not limited to young adults. A Gallup News poll also shows a steady decline in Trump's approval among the broader independent voter bloc, a trend that is often a bellwether for a president's political health. The data suggests that the momentum of his 2024 victory has largely stalled as he navigates the complexities of a second term.[2]

The Generational Great Divide: Why Young Voters Are Fading on Trump

The youth vote has long been a complex and unpredictable force in American politics, but as a group, they are increasingly loyal to policy, not party.[3] Harry Enten's analysis points to a significant source of this discontent: a generation of college graduates who feel they have done everything right but are left with nothing to show for it.[4] This feeling of being "mad as hell" is driving a lot of the dissatisfaction.[4]

A Crisis of Economic Reality

For young people, the economic reality of 2025 is stark. A CIRCLE Post-2024 Election Youth Poll found that the cost of living and inflation were "far and away" the top issues for young voters, with 64% citing them as a top-three concern.[5] This financial strain is felt more acutely by young Americans than by older generations, as they are relatively new to the job market and earn significantly less than their older counterparts.[6]

The job market for Gen Z has become particularly challenging. A Randstad survey reveals that global job postings for entry-level roles have declined by a massive 29 percentage points since January 2024.[7] This has led to a crisis of job opportunities for recent graduates, with many feeling anxious about their ability to find employment. A Bank of America report notes that the unemployment rate for young workers has climbed to 7.4% in June, and more than 13% of unemployed Americans are new entrants to the workforce with no prior experience.[8]

The economic squeeze goes beyond job opportunities. Many young adults are struggling to meet basic needs, with more than 40% of youth reporting they "often" or "sometimes" find it difficult to make ends meet.[5] This is compounded by a dramatic rise in the cost of rent and mortgages, which has forced many to move back in with their parents, and an increase in credit card debt for Gen Z by approximately 14% from 2022 to 2023.[6]

The Burden of Student Debt and Broken Promises

Student debt is arguably the most significant economic challenge for young people. With over 43 million U.S. borrowers owing more than $1.6 trillion in federal student loans alone, student debt now exceeds debt from auto loans and credit cards.[9] The promise of student loan forgiveness was a key issue for young voters in 2020, and the failure to deliver on those promises has created a deep sense of betrayal and anxiety.[6]

Recent policy changes under the Trump administration have only worsened the situation for many borrowers. The new Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), which replaced previous income-driven repayment plans, has been widely criticized. Under RAP, borrowers are forced into a system that is "likely to be unaffordable for many," with monthly payments required even for those earning below the poverty level.[10] The new plan extends the maximum repayment term to 30 years, a change that many believe will trap the lowest-income borrowers in debt for decades.[10] These changes, coupled with a lack of clarity and guidance from the Education Department, have left borrowers feeling "paralyzed, anxious and misled," leading to a sentiment of being let down after their hopes for relief were dashed.[11]

Shifting Sands: The Voter of Color Coalition

The most surprising story of the 2024 election was Trump's significant gains among voters of color. As Harry Enten noted, Trump's performance with African-Americans, Hispanics, and Asians was a major factor in his victory.[12, 13] Pre-election and exit polls confirmed this trend, showing a broad-based shift to Republicans that was consistent across cities, suburbs, and rural areas.[12] However, this newfound support appears to be highly conditional and is already beginning to unravel.

From "Inroads" to Backlash

Several post-election polls have tracked a sharp decline in Trump's approval among voters of color. According to a national survey of Hispanic voters by Equis Research, Trump's job approval is trending below his 2024 support.[14] While 44% of Hispanic voters supported him in 2024, his current approval rating among the group is only 38%.[14] Most notably, 15% of Latinos who voted for Trump in 2024 now disapprove of his performance.[14]

The situation is even more dire among Black voters. A Newsweek/Economist/YouGov poll found that Trump's net approval rating among Black voters has dropped by a staggering 25 points since May.[15] The most recent data shows a net approval rating of -73, with just 11% of Black respondents approving of his job performance.[15] A broader analysis from the Pew Research Center confirms this trend, with clear majorities of Black (83%), Hispanic (70%), and Asian (66%) Americans expressing disapproval of his performance in office.[1]

Immigration and the Economic Disconnect

The reasons for this reversal are multifaceted. On immigration, a topic where Trump previously found a receptive audience among voters of color, he now faces a backlash. Harry Enten pointed out that a key insight often missed by the media was that many voters of color distinguished between being "anti-illegal immigration" and being against all immigrants.[12] A poll from Equis Research confirms this, showing that by a wide 66-29 margin, Hispanic voters believe Trump's "actions are going too far and targeting the types of immigrants who strengthen our nation."[14] This indicates that while many may support border security, they are alienated by what they perceive as an overly aggressive and indiscriminate approach to immigration policy.

Additionally, the economy, which was once a major strength for Trump, is now becoming a weakness. The Equis poll notes that Trump's grade on the economy (36-62) now lags behind his overall approval.[14] This is a significant change, as Democrats are now more trusted than Republicans on the cost of living and the economy, a notable shift from the previous election cycle when those were Republican advantages.[14]

The Future of the Electorate: What's Next for 2026 and Beyond?

The demographic trends are undeniable. By 2026, Gen Z will become the first majority nonwhite generation in American history.[3] The U.S. Census Bureau projects that the nation will become "minority white" by 2045, with racial minorities accounting for all of the nation's youthful population growth.[16] These shifts mean that the Republican Party's coalition will need to continue to diversify to remain competitive. While Trump made historic inroads with these voters, the post-election data suggests that this support is far from locked in.

The 2024 election was remarkably close, with Republicans winning the House of Representatives by the fewest seats for a majority party since there were 50 states.[12, 13] The phenomenon of "ticket splitting"—where voters chose Trump for president while also favoring Democratic congressional candidates—demonstrates the fluidity of the modern electorate.[12, 13] The data on young voters and voters of color further highlights this instability, suggesting that a political strategy focused on short-term gains at the expense of long-term loyalty is a risky one. The upcoming 2026 midterm elections will be a critical test of whether these trends represent a temporary blip or a more significant, lasting erosion of Trump's support.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Why did young voters turn towards Trump in the 2024 election?

A: While young voters still favored Kamala Harris in 2024, they did so by a much smaller margin than in 2020. Polling data indicates that many young voters were primarily concerned with economic issues like the cost of living, inflation, and jobs, which were seen as key weaknesses for the Democratic party.[5, 17]

Q: What specific economic issues are most concerning to young voters?

A: Key concerns for young voters include inflation, the cost of living, student loan debt, and a difficult job market with a significant drop in entry-level positions. These issues are disproportionately affecting young adults as they try to establish themselves in the workforce.[6, 7, 8]

Q: Did Trump's approval drop with other voting blocs as well?

A: Yes. While the drop has been most significant among young voters, Trump has also lost ground with non-voters from 2024 and even a small percentage of his own 2024 voters.[1] The data indicates a broader, albeit less pronounced, shift in sentiment away from the president since the election.

Q: Why did some voters of color shift their support to Trump in 2024?

A: According to Harry Enten, many voters of color, particularly Hispanic voters, made a key distinction between being against illegal immigration and being anti-immigrant. While Trump's rhetoric was seen as strong on immigration, his more recent policies have alienated some of these voters who feel he has gone too far.[12, 14] The economy and inflation were also major factors, as many felt that Democratic policies were not addressing their financial concerns.[14]

Conclusion: The Road Ahead for a Fragile Coalition

The post-election decline in support for Donald Trump among young voters and voters of color is a powerful warning sign. It suggests that while his populist message on the economy and immigration helped him secure a win, the long-term loyalty of these new supporters is far from guaranteed. These voters are not ideological purists; they are pragmatic and motivated by a desire for tangible change and economic stability.

The Republican Party's ability to maintain its newly expanded coalition hinges on its capacity to address the deep-seated economic anxieties facing young Americans and the nuanced views of voters of color on issues like immigration. Failure to do so could result in these key demographics reverting to their previous political leanings, a move that would likely spell trouble for the GOP in future elections.

The story of the 2024 election was about Trump's surprising gains with these groups. The story of his second term may very well be about how he failed to keep them. The next two years will be a test of whether a coalition built on discontent can withstand the pressures of governing. The data so far suggests that the challenge is immense.

Poll: Which issue do you think is most important to swing voters today?

• The Economy / Cost of Living
• Immigration Policy
• Social Issues (e.g., abortion, rights)
• Foreign Policy

Comment section is enabled for your insights and discussion.

Stay Ahead of the Political Curve

Don't miss our next deep-dive analysis. Subscribe to get expert insights delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe Today